| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tailgates Bar & Grill | 8.9 | $19.20 | Welland |
| Rose City Pizza | 8.9 | $16.90 | Welland |
| Luciano's Pizzeria | 8.9 | $19.15 | Welland |
| Angelina's Pizzeria | 8.8 | $15.54 | Welland |
| Volcano Pizzeria | 8.8 | $13.50 | Welland |
| Matteo's Ristorante | 8.7 | $19.21 | Welland |
| Antonios Pizzeria | 8.6 | $16.95 | Welland |
| Mario's Place | 8.6 | $16.75 | Welland |
| Handlebar Hanks Roadhouse | 8.2 | $19.20 | Welland |
| The Rex Hotel | 7.8 | $16.39 | Welland |
| Boston Pizza | 7.3 | $31.06 | Welland |
| Wings Block | 7.2 | $16.33 | Welland |
| Red Swan Pizza Thin Crust | 7.2 | $13.50 | Welland |
| Vincent's Pizzeria | 7.1 | $17.50 | Welland |
| For Pizza’s Sake | 6.8 | $25.98 | Welland |
| Ever Fresh Pizza | 6.7 | $13.55 | Welland |
| Four Seasons Bakery | 6.7 | $30.00 | Welland |
| The Kavern | 6.4 | $16.94 | Welland |
| Pizza Hut Homestyle Crust | 6.4 | $22.31 | Welland |
| Pizza Pizza Seaway Mall | 6.3 | $11.85 | Welland |
| Gino's Pizza Seaway Mall | 6.2 | $13.56 | Welland |
| Twice The Deal Pizza | 6.1 | $10.16 | Welland |
| Trappers Sports Bar | 5.7 | $18.03 | Welland |
| CC's Dugout Italian Eatery | 5.5 | $15.00 | Welland |
| Domino’s Pepperoni Feast Pizza | 4.6 | $17.00 | Welland |
| Little Caesars Pizza | 2.5 | $14.68 | Welland |
| Name | Score | Price | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| Luciano's Pizzaria | 9.1 | $15.77 | Welland |
| Marios Place | 8.6 | $13.00 | Welland |
| Antonios Pizzeria | 8.5 | $11.85 | Welland |
| Rose City Pizza | 8.4 | $13.50 | Welland |
| Volcaneo's Pizzeria | 8.4 | $9.95 | Welland |
| Handlebar Hanks | 8.3 | $9.59 | Welland |
| The Rex Hotel | 8.1 | $15.26 | Welland |
| Tailgates Bar and Grill | 7.9 | $10.99 | Welland |
| Angelina's Pizza | 7.3 | $11.60 | Welland |
| Matteos Ristorante | 7.2 | $15.00 | Welland |
| Vincent's Red Hot Pizza & Subs | 6.1 | $9.61 | Welland |